Politics

Newsom’s death row clemency faces Republican lawsuit

Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Nov. 5 that he is commuting the sentences of all 548 people on California’s death row to life without parole, the largest act of mass clemency in US history.  Now, Republicans and a growing bloc of district attorneys are racing to stop the commutations. In an open letter, Newsom frames his…

Lethal injection table in California’s former San Quentin execution chamber, viewed through witness room glass.
In this Sept. 21, 2010 photo is the lethal injection facility at San Quentin State Prison in San Quentin, Calif. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File)

Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Nov. 5 that he is commuting the sentences of all 548 people on California’s death row to life without parole, the largest act of mass clemency in US history. 

Now, Republicans and a growing bloc of district attorneys are racing to stop the commutations.

In an open letter, Newsom frames his decision as a moral one. Newsom said he believes  “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values” and that it “undermines the foundations of our legal system.” He wrote, “I know we cannot execute people in an imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them, justice and human decency.”

Newsom’s statement acknowledges the pattern of racial bias in the criminal justice system. Black and Latino individuals make up a significant majority of California’s death row population and face severe, documented racial disparities in capital punishment. 


The GOP backlash and subsequent lawsuit

Republicans reacted swiftly to Newsom’s mass clemency. On Nov. 16, district attorneys from 30 counties filed a lawsuit at the California Supreme Court asking it to halt the commutations, arguing Newsom acted unlawfully by not giving crime victims a chance to be heard.

President Trump called the move a “disaster for Justice in America” on Truth Social. State Sen. Suzette Martinez Valladares (R-Santa Clarita) branded Newsom a “Killer of Justice,” calling the commutations a betrayal of victims’ families.

Anne Marie Schubert, a former Sacramento County district attorney who now leads the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, spoke against Newsom’s decision during a press conference on Nov. 13. 

Schubert argued the state Supreme Court has historically reviewed clemency requests from people with multiple felonies one by one rather than approving them as a group.

Notifying victims’ families before granting clemency

The lawsuit argues that Newsom broke the law by not giving victims a chance to be heard. However, Newsom says this rule applies only to people who apply for clemency, and he doesn’t need anyone to apply in order to grant it. 

The California Constitution lets the Legislature set rules for clemency applicants, but those rules don’t limit the Governor’s power to grant it. Courts and the Attorney General have agreed that the Legislature can’t restrict this executive power. 

Under standard procedures, the victim’s families are heard mainly through the district attorney, and their input is documented in writing. Once the applicant sends a request for Notice of Intention to Apply for Executive Clemency, the district attorney must make reasonable efforts to notify the victims of the crimes related to the application and the victims’ families, who may also submit a recommendation to the Governor for or against commutation

In an explanatory statement, Newsom maintains that he is operating within his executive authority to grant clemency in criminal cases. He asserts those rules don’t apply because no prisoner applied and he acted on his own initiative. 

Newsom said his office will notify district attorneys after the commutations go to the court and will ask them to help reach victims.

An expensive system with infrequent executions

California has spent an estimated $6.8 billion on its death penalty system since 1978 while executing only 13 people, according to the American Civil Liberties Union. The state’s last execution took place in January 2006. Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions in 2019, but that left the sentences themselves in place.

The commutations cover 529 men and 19 women, according to numbers provided by his office. The state constitution, however, requires a Supreme Court recommendation before a governor can commute the sentence of anyone convicted of more than one felony, and at least four justices must concur. 

According to the Death Penalty Information Center, if all are approved by the California Supreme Court, the move would shrink the nation’s death row population by nearly 30%. 

The fight now heads to court, and what happens next depends on the justices. The court has not said how or when it will review the 382 pending cases it must approve. 

The 382 cases needing approval involve people with more than one felony conviction, typically a prior felony from before the murder that led to the death sentence. The legal distinction comes from a provision in the California Constitution that treats repeat offenders differently from first-time offenders when it comes to clemency.

The remaining cases involve people whose only felony record is the case that put them on death row, so Newsom’s order alone is enough.


Categories:

Authors

  • Michelle Zacarias is an award-winning journalist and the lead Political Correspondent for the Courier California. As a 2023-25 UC Berkeley California Local News Fellow, she covered politics, immigration, civic engagement, and equity throughout Southern California. Michelle is also the host of The Latino Newsletter Podcast and a two-time cancer survivor. 

    Have a story tip? Reach Michelle at michellezacarias@couriernewsroom.com. For local reporting that connects the dots, from policy to people, sign up for her free newsletter here.